Blab Sports
Cardinals Face Trade-Deadline Decisions on Dustin May, Jordan Walker and Lars Nootbaar
When the trade deadline looms, the St. Louis Cardinals are staring down a trio of roster crossroads that could shape the franchise’s short‑term competitiveness and long‑term future.
Right‑hander Dustin May, who inked a one‑year deal for 2026 with a mutual option for 2027, has posted a 4.55 ERA and a 64.7% strand rate in the current campaign. His ground‑ball rate sits just above league average, yet his 0.317 average on balls in play and a 7.3% homer‑to‑flyball ratio reveal a pitcher still vulnerable to hard contact. May logged 132 1/3 innings last season—his career high—and is now 39 innings shy of that mark. A history of injuries and the signs of wear only add to the uncertainty.
Chaim Bloom, the Cardinals’ President of Baseball Operations, has repeatedly underscored that the club remains committed to long‑term planning, even as the team has outperformed expectations this year. Bloom’s remarks suggest the organization is open to a trade if a suitable return can be secured. A qualifying offer of $23 million would only trigger a compensatory first‑round pick if May declines and signs a free‑agent contract worth more than $50 million—a scenario Bloom considers unlikely. Consequently, the Cardinals would need to move May within the next two weeks for the best available return and then fill the rotation with either a veteran or a younger arm still under club control.
One option the front office has floated is acquiring a veteran starter such as Robbie Ray. A trade that brings in a reliable arm would align with the Cardinals’ short‑term competitiveness while preserving the organization’s prospect pipeline, which the pitching staff has been criticized for lacking.
At 24, right‑fielder Jordan Walker has captured the spotlight with a breakout 2026 season. Drafted in the first round of the 2020 MLB draft, Walker won the Home Run Derby and earned an All‑Star nod the same year. His derby earnings even outpaced his current salary, underscoring the upside he offers the club. While no extension has yet been announced, the Cardinals are expected to weigh a contract that reflects Walker’s growing role as a key offensive contributor.
Lars Nootbaar, a right‑handed outfielder drafted in the eighth round of the 2018 MLB draft, remains a “data darling” who has yet to fully break through. His trade value is debated, but some reports suggest he could be a target for teams seeking a versatile outfielder or a controllable young player. The Cardinals’ front office has not released a specific trade package for Nootbaar, and no concrete trade targets have been named.
The 2026 season for the Cardinals is a study in contrast: unexpected success on the field paired with lingering uncertainty in the pitching department. The possibility of trading a veteran like May, extending a promising young player like Walker, or moving a potential trade asset like Nootbaar illustrates the delicate balance the organization must strike between staying competitive and building for the future.
As the deadline draws near, the Cardinals will likely evaluate offers for May and assess the financial and competitive implications of extending Walker. The organization’s long‑term strategy, as articulated by Bloom, will guide decisions on whether to retain or trade these players while preserving a strong prospect pipeline.
The outcome of these negotiations will impact the Cardinals’ playoff chances, the composition of the starting rotation, and the future of key young talents. Fans, analysts, and rival teams will watch closely as the Cardinals navigate the trade‑deadline maze.
Right‑hander Dustin May, who inked a one‑year deal for 2026 with a mutual option for 2027, has posted a 4.55 ERA and a 64.7% strand rate in the current campaign. His ground‑ball rate sits just above league average, yet his 0.317 average on balls in play and a 7.3% homer‑to‑flyball ratio reveal a pitcher still vulnerable to hard contact. May logged 132 1/3 innings last season—his career high—and is now 39 innings shy of that mark. A history of injuries and the signs of wear only add to the uncertainty.
Chaim Bloom, the Cardinals’ President of Baseball Operations, has repeatedly underscored that the club remains committed to long‑term planning, even as the team has outperformed expectations this year. Bloom’s remarks suggest the organization is open to a trade if a suitable return can be secured. A qualifying offer of $23 million would only trigger a compensatory first‑round pick if May declines and signs a free‑agent contract worth more than $50 million—a scenario Bloom considers unlikely. Consequently, the Cardinals would need to move May within the next two weeks for the best available return and then fill the rotation with either a veteran or a younger arm still under club control.
One option the front office has floated is acquiring a veteran starter such as Robbie Ray. A trade that brings in a reliable arm would align with the Cardinals’ short‑term competitiveness while preserving the organization’s prospect pipeline, which the pitching staff has been criticized for lacking.
At 24, right‑fielder Jordan Walker has captured the spotlight with a breakout 2026 season. Drafted in the first round of the 2020 MLB draft, Walker won the Home Run Derby and earned an All‑Star nod the same year. His derby earnings even outpaced his current salary, underscoring the upside he offers the club. While no extension has yet been announced, the Cardinals are expected to weigh a contract that reflects Walker’s growing role as a key offensive contributor.
Lars Nootbaar, a right‑handed outfielder drafted in the eighth round of the 2018 MLB draft, remains a “data darling” who has yet to fully break through. His trade value is debated, but some reports suggest he could be a target for teams seeking a versatile outfielder or a controllable young player. The Cardinals’ front office has not released a specific trade package for Nootbaar, and no concrete trade targets have been named.
The 2026 season for the Cardinals is a study in contrast: unexpected success on the field paired with lingering uncertainty in the pitching department. The possibility of trading a veteran like May, extending a promising young player like Walker, or moving a potential trade asset like Nootbaar illustrates the delicate balance the organization must strike between staying competitive and building for the future.
As the deadline draws near, the Cardinals will likely evaluate offers for May and assess the financial and competitive implications of extending Walker. The organization’s long‑term strategy, as articulated by Bloom, will guide decisions on whether to retain or trade these players while preserving a strong prospect pipeline.
The outcome of these negotiations will impact the Cardinals’ playoff chances, the composition of the starting rotation, and the future of key young talents. Fans, analysts, and rival teams will watch closely as the Cardinals navigate the trade‑deadline maze.
